What we have here is a failure to capitulate

Share this article:
What we have here is a failure to capitulate
What we have here is a failure to capitulate
The saga of Donald Berwick as administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services took an interesting, if not sadly predictable, turn last week. Opponents of his patron, President Obama, called for Berwick to be pulled from consideration for renomination.

If the president could stick out his tongue and appoint Berwick during a Congressional recess last summer, well, the lawmakers in the minority in Washington could return the compliment. Forty-two Republican U.S. Senators, to be exact, did just that when they sent a letter to Obama. It cited Berwick's lack of experience running a major insurance operation and past statements that rankled political conservatives as proof positive he was unfit for the job.

Berwick needs Senate confirmation by the end of the year or, by law, must leave office. Mildly interested friends of mine were dumbfounded to learn that just 41 Senators (out of 100) were needed to block such an appointment. So much for majority rule. But we digress. Obama's opponents appear to have more than enough firepower to derail the nomination.

What happens from here is uncertain, except that the White House has said the nomination will stand. No surrender. And that's the way it should be. If Obama believes in his man, let him stand up to scrutiny during confirmation hearings. Obama got his head start with the backdoor appointment last year. So far, Berwick has faced congressional inquisitors on a limited basis, on other topics, reasonably well.

Give this until fall for hearings to begin and Berwick will have had more than a year to prove himself. Of course, some politicians and apparatchniks never prove themselves in some people's eyes. But why not give it a try if you're the administration? The worst that could happen would be that Berwick gets pilloried in public. But over what? So far, he's done nothing worse than implement the administration's plans. No statements about modeling the American healthcare system after Britain's. And no other mumblings like those from the past that have Republicans hypothesizing and hyperventilating all at the same time. The "smoking gun" they want to wave around the room hasn't been fired—not since Berwick was given the scepter anyway.

If after hearings, Berwick gets booted, so be it. By accepting the post, he surely must have known he'd need his big boy pants at some point. If the end result of his tenure as CMS chief becomes showing once again that obstructionism is a less arduous way to govern than using creativity or independent thinking, well, then the effort would not have been totally in vain.

Share this article:

Next Article in Daily Editors' Notes

Daily Editors' Notes

McKnight's Daily Editor's Notes features commentary on the latest in long-term care news. Entries are written by Editorial Director John O'Connor on Monday and Friday; Staff Writer Tim Mullaney on Tuesday, Editor James M. Berklan on Wednesday and Senior Editor Elizabeth Newman on Thursday.


    More in Daily Editors' Notes

    Guess who's asking whether to discontinue skilled care?

    Guess who's asking whether to discontinue skilled care?

    The audience member had a question that in previous years would have been found at the corner of Blasphemy and Crazytalk. She wanted to know whether it would be advisable ...

    Managing time for staff to reflect after a resident's death

    Managing time for staff to reflect after a ...

    Singing "Amazing Grace" or playing a ukelele version of "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" may not immediately spring to mind as ways to help staff members grieve after a resident has ...

    Glen Campbell Alzheimer's documentary brings out the stars — caregivers and celebrities ...

    As readers of this blog may recall, my expectations for the special screening of the new documentary about music superstar Glen Campbell's journey with Alzheimer's disease were high. Sunday night's star-studded showing and concert were to be unlike anything long-term care professionals had experienced before. ...