Daily Editors' Notes

Spare us the false hope about Alzheimer's

Share this article:
John O'Connor
John O'Connor

Here we go again: This week saw the release of yet another breathless study claiming the cure for Alzheimer's disease is getting closer — maybe.

The latest incantation is a report in Nature Genetics. This entry touts an international study of the disease that may help us unlock a cure. Unless, of course, it doesn't.

It seems like we get treated to at least one or two of these “important breakthrough” studies every month, sometimes more. And the plot seldom varies: Earnest investigators working countless hours have issued a report that may bring us closer to a cure. Then, tucked somewhere in the back is a mention that, ahem, more research is needed.

Thanks for the update. Self-fulfilling prophecy, Alzheimer's investigation is thy name.

Don't get me wrong. I realize Alzheimer's is a terrible, terrible disease. It robs its victims of their memories and personalities. There are 5 million people in our nation currently afflicted, and the numbers going forward do not look good. Alzheimer's truly is a national tragedy. And that's part of the reason why a constant deluge of hyperventilating updates is not just annoying.

For despite what we are sometimes being led to believe, each new investigation does not necessarily bring us closer to a cure. And until one provably does, it's just another study. So can we put the “important breakthrough” rhetoric on hold until, well, there actually is an important breakthrough?

These reports may not be intentionally cynical or misleading. Regardless, they are giving false hope to millions of people. Haven't those folks suffered enough already?

John O'Connor is Editorial Director at McKnight's.

Share this article:

Next Article in Daily Editors' Notes

Daily Editors' Notes

McKnight's Daily Editor's Notes features commentary on the latest in long-term care news. Entries are written by Editorial Director John O'Connor on Monday and Friday; Staff Writer Tim Mullaney on Tuesday, Editor James M. Berklan on Wednesday and Senior Editor Elizabeth Newman on Thursday.


    More in Daily Editors' Notes

    There's an app for that, but should there be?

    There's an app for that, but should there ...

    Some apps - like those that are meant to track blood pressure or give medication reminders - are geared toward your future residents. And that's where the trouble can arise, ...

    Could you make money if Mom's nursing home does a good job?

    Could you make money if Mom's nursing home ...

    A man recently raised more than $51,000 ... to make potato salad. And in a similar type of online campaign, senior living investment company Mainstreet raised more than $1.6 million ...

    Finally, a Medicaid funding plan that actually makes sense

    Finally, a Medicaid funding plan that actually makes ...

    When politicians talk about Medicaid funding and nursing homes these days, an unsettling theme often emerges: the need to spend less of the former on the latter.