Nursing homes lukewarm to government's new five-star rating system

Share this article:
Bruce Yarwood, AHCA CEO
Bruce Yarwood, AHCA CEO
Nursing home operators wasted little time Wednesday issuing rebuttals to the federal government's announcement that it would create and publish individual facility rankings on its Web site by the end of the year.

While lauding the goal of delivering better care to residents, providers immediately pushed for the inclusion of consumer and staff satisfaction survey results in the matrix that will determine rankings. They also uniformly criticized the current survey and certification system, which will heavily influence rankings, according to regulators.

"Although we applaud the longstanding work of CMS, we do not believe that an index which relies upon a broken survey system is an accurate way to measure quality," said Bruce Yarwood, president and CEO of the American Health Care Association, in a statement prepared before government officials made their formal announcement.

"A rating system that helps consumers identify both high and low performing nursing homes is essential," added Larry Minnix of the American Association of Homes and Services for the Aging. Minnix said the system should be based on four "pillars:" consumer satisficaction, staff satisfaction, clinical outcomes and public oversight.

"The public oversight process will be the most controversial because that pillar is the most developed, yet has the largest cracks in its foundation," Minnix said in a statement. "Numerous expert opinions and reports speak to its inconsistency, subjectivity, lack of timeliness and unintelligibility to the public."

This will be the first time that CMS will offer such a rating system for the fee-for-service, or traditional Medicare program. Last year, the agency initiated a star rating system for health and prescription drug plans that are available to Medicare beneficiaries.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services is soliciting comments from all interested parties over the summer months, when the criteria and method of creating the rankings will be determined, said Acting Administrator Kerry Weems.

A sample of what a five-star ranking Web view could look like is available at Comments may be sent to Weems added during a special conference call Wednesday that facilities' star rankings would likely be updated quarterly.
Share this article:

Next Article in News

More in News

Skilled nursing facilities with poor quality ratings do not readmit more patients to hospitals, researchers find

Skilled nursing facilities with poor quality ratings do ...

Low-quality and high-quality skilled nursing facilities readmit about the same proportion of residents to hospitals, suggest research findings recently published in the American Journal of Medical Quality.

Cipro and related antibiotics increase MRSA risk in long-term care facilities, study ...

Long-term care residents on a fluoroquinolone antibiotic such as Cipro are at an increased risk for methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, researchers in France have found.

Jonathan Blum, who oversaw long-term care reforms, resigns as head of Medicare

The nation's top Medicare official, Jonathan Blum, is leaving his post next month, news outlets reported Tuesday. Blum became a familiar figure to long-term care providers through Open Door Forum calls and other outreach efforts during his five-year tenure, as he guided implementation of Medicare ...