Not-for-profit nursing homes provide better care, on average, than for-profits, research suggests

Share this article:
Not-for-profit nursing homes provide better care, on average, than for-profits, research suggests
Not-for-profit nursing homes provide better care, on average, than for-profits, research suggests
U.S. not-for-profit nursing homes, on average, deliver higher quality care than for-profit nursing homes, an analysis of observational studies suggests.  

A multiprovince team of Canadian researchers reviewed 82 studies of nursing home quality to determine the care differences between for-profit and not-for-profit nursing homes. Some of the studies dated as far back as 1965. The most recent results were from 2003. Of the 82 studies, 40 conclusively demonstrated that not-for-profit nursing homes had performed better on four key quality-of-care measures, while only two found that for-profit facilities had performed better. The rest showed mixed results. The quality-of-care measures studied were staffing levels, pressure ulcer rates, use of restraints and fewer government citations.

Researchers point out that a number of variables, such as a lack of a uniform definition of "quality of care," influence the results. For-profit and not-for-profit facilities have different motives and structures, researchers note. Also, it's difficult to adjust for factors such as staff turnover rates and management style. As a result, while the averages and trends found in this study appear to favor not-for-profit homes, the report should not be used to judge all institutions, researchers say. The study was published online August 4 in the British Medical Journal.

Share this article:

More in News

A small team of workers responds best in emergencies, expert says

A small team of workers responds best in ...

Long-term care providers should consider a "flat" crisis management approach that relies on a core group of staff members, experts advised Wednesday at the LeadingAge annual conference.

Nursing homes have better pain and catheter management if leaders have more ...

Nursing homes led by administrators and directors of nursing with higher levels of education and certification have better outcomes on some key quality measures, according to recently published findings.

Court green-lights charges that a healthcare network underused observation stays

A whistleblower can continue to pursue charges that a Nevada healthcare network routinely admitted people as hospital inpatients when they should have been placed in observation status, a federal appeals court recently ruled.