It's time frivolous lawsuit filers were held more accountable

Share this article:
John O'Connor
John O'Connor

Not all the news out of Congress these days is bad. Last week, the House passed long-overdue legislation that fines plaintiffs who file frivolous lawsuits.

Rep. Lamar Smith (R-TX) is the bill's sponsor. He accurately noted that many people who file these bogus cases are never held accountable.

“In recent years, frivolous lawsuits have been filed against the Weather Channel for failing to accurately predict storms, against television shows [that] people claimed were too scary, and against fast-food companies because inactive children gained weight,” he said. He could have just as easily cited the litany of strange cases in the senior living sector.

The approved House legislation attempts to reduce wasteful litigation by making sanctions against frivolous claims mandatory rather than discretionary under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. The measure also eliminates a 21-day "safe harbor" period for a plaintiff's lawyer to withdraw a lawsuit without penalty.

"A generation ago, the rule meant to hold lawyers accountable for bringing frivolous lawsuits was watered down,” said Lisa A. Rickard, president of the U.S. Chamber Institute for Legal Reform. “What followed was litigation wave that left in its wake increased insurance costs, job losses, and a near total breakdown of attorney accountability.”

Amen. Knucklehead cases cost long-term care providers many dollars and many hours of wasted time each year. Relief here would be welcome indeed. And just so I'm clear, I have no problem with legitimate cases being filed. Operators who shirk their caregiving duties or abuse residents should be out of business, and probably in prison.

But all too often, people seem to feel that when bad things happen, someone else must pay. Lifelong smokers sue tobacco companies and obese people go after fast-food restaurants as if they had no say in the matter. Who gave us the notion that this is an acceptable position? Trial lawyers? Sympathetic juries? Politicians? It's utterly bizarre, yet it happens all too often.

We live in a world where the luckiest among us get old and sick before we die. Fortunately, senior living options exist to make the endgame more comfortable and less painful than it otherwise would be. And while it's one thing to hold operators responsible for bad care, it's another to blame them for life's inescapable realities. Yet all too often, that's the driving factor behind many cases that never should have been filed.

Putting the brakes on shameless cases isn't just good for the long-term care field. It's good for America.

Share this article:

Next Article in Daily Editors' Notes

Daily Editors' Notes

McKnight's Daily Editor's Notes features commentary on the latest in long-term care news. Entries are written by Editorial Director John O'Connor on Monday and Friday; Staff Writer Tim Mullaney on Tuesday, Editor James M. Berklan on Wednesday and Senior Editor Elizabeth Newman on Thursday.


    More in Daily Editors' Notes

    Guess who's asking whether to discontinue skilled care?

    Guess who's asking whether to discontinue skilled care?

    The audience member had a question that in previous years would have been found at the corner of Blasphemy and Crazytalk. She wanted to know whether it would be advisable ...

    Managing time for staff to reflect after a resident's death

    Managing time for staff to reflect after a ...

    Singing "Amazing Grace" or playing a ukelele version of "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" may not immediately spring to mind as ways to help staff members grieve after a resident has ...

    Glen Campbell Alzheimer's documentary brings out the stars — caregivers and celebrities ...

    As readers of this blog may recall, my expectations for the special screening of the new documentary about music superstar Glen Campbell's journey with Alzheimer's disease were high. Sunday night's star-studded showing and concert were to be unlike anything long-term care professionals had experienced before. ...