Ask the legal expert

Share this article:
Attorney John Durso, Ungaretti & Harris LLP
Attorney John Durso, Ungaretti & Harris LLP
What are the most important lessons from the trial of the Manganos, the New Orleans facility owners who didn't evacuate for Hurricane Katrina and were recently acquitted of negligent homicide charges?

The primary lesson to be learned is that providers of services to frail elderly or disabled resident populations must have a disaster evacuation plan in place that complies with all federal, state and local requirements. Furthermore, when a disaster takes place, the provider must have made arrangements to safely and in a timely manner place residents in a secure and as safe as possible location.

Failure to have such a disaster plan, as well as failure to properly execute any necessary evacuation plans, could lead to governmental fines and penalties, as well as civil law exposure for damages under negligence theories.

Providers are faced with an almost Catch-22 situation, as liability might arise for failure to evacuate, evacuating when not necessary, or alleged poorly executed evacuations (e.g., inadequate or unsafe transportation).

In all potential evacuation situations, providers should notify state officials who oversee the provider and obtain, whenever possible, their consent or affirmation of a decision to evacuate or stay put. Even if these governmental overseers will not participate in the decision-making, the provider, by at least notifying public officials, might help a finding of the necessary intent or other requirements of a crime.

Regardless of the outcome of a criminal case, even though the providers might ultimately be found not guilty of a crime, to respond to a criminal prosecution can be costly, time consuming – and a nightmare. Fate as to jail time could hinge on an unpredictable jury viewing the situation after a terrible outcome by focusing on deaths or serious injuries that resulted.
Share this article:
close

Next Article in News

More in News

Rape investigation blocked by nursing home's HIPAA concerns, authorities say ...

Florida authorities say a nursing home is citing privacy laws to impede the investigation of a possible resident rape, according to local news reports.

Jury hands down $14 million negligent care verdict to 'send message' to nursing homes

Jury hands down $14 million negligent care verdict ...

A Massachusetts jury has awarded $14 million to the family of a nursing home resident who died due to a pressure ulcer, dehydration and other conditions linked to negligent care, ...

CCRC executive director salaries hold steady, therapy directors get boost

Continuing care retirement community executive director salaries have barely increased in the past year, while therapy and rehabilitation directors received a boost, a new report shows. The average salary for a therapy and rehab director is currently $95,905.