Ask the legal expert: How will the legal system handle healthcare reform lawsuits?

Share this article:
Attorney John Durso, Ungaretti & Harris LLP
Attorney John Durso, Ungaretti & Harris LLP
Q: We've been hearing a lot about the legal attacks against the healthcare reform law. Is it likely that the courts will throw it out?

A: The legality of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act is an issue of  high importance to healthcare providers. Parts of the Act already have taken effect, and the remainder of the Act will phase in until 2014. On June 8, 2011, a three-judge panel of the Court of Appeals in Atlanta heard oral arguments in the federal government's appeal of a Florida District Court's decision to overturn the entire act.
 
The District Court declared a provision of the act to be unconstitional, that of the “individual mandate.” The court held that the mandate is not severable from the remainder of the bill, and thus the entire act is unconstitutional and unenforceable.

One other District Court had earlier come to the same conclusion regarding the constitutionality of the mandate but did not find the entire act unconstitutional. Three other district courts have held that the mandate is constitutional, and two other federal courts are considering separate but similar legal challenges to the act.

It is widely believed that the debate over the mandate will reach the Supreme Court within the next few years, and it is difficult to predict what the court will decide. Whatever the outcome, it is likely that many of the Act's requirements affecting senior living facilities will remain in effect in some form because Congress will be free to pass provisions of the act that are not directly related to the mandate.

Moreover, many government agencies already have promulgated regulations to implement provisions of the act. Providers should take steps to ensure they are compliant with these federal rules.

Please send your legal questions to John Durso at ltcnews@mcknights.com.
Share this article:
close

Next Article in News

More in News

Expert says providers often wrongly threatened by PEPPER reports

Instead of fearing further scrutiny by federal authorities, providers should embrace the opportunity to get feedback in the form of PEPPER reports, legal experts said Monday at the LeadingAge annual meeting in Nashville.

Healthcare reform already driving diverse, dynamic long-term care models, LeadingAge leaders say

Healthcare reform already driving diverse, dynamic long-term care ...

One way to gauge the effects is healthcare reform is by looking at ongoing changes to the continuing care retirement community model, LeadingAge officials said Monday at the association's annual ...

Federal court: Nursing home can be sued for firing hairdresser who can ...

Is the ability to transport residents in their wheelchairs an essential function of a nursing home hairdresser? A federal appeals court says it's a valid question and is allowing a hairdresser to sue a facility that fired her.